History & Mystery · Documented history

Winter Behind the Pass

Sierra Nevada, near present-day Donner Lake and Alder Creek, California · Winter 1846–1847

Content note: Starvation, deaths and children losing parents. Non-graphic.

Text

In 1846, a group of emigrants travelling towards California took the Hastings Cutoff. The supposed shortcut brought costly delays. Through part of the Wasatch Mountains, they had to make a route for their wagons; the National Park Service describes sixteen days spent reaching the Great Salt Lake Valley. Time lost on the trail would matter when they reached the Sierra Nevada late in the season.

Among the travellers was three-year-old Eliza Donner. Snow prevented the party from crossing the mountains, and separate camps formed near the lake now called Donner Lake and at Alder Creek. The Donner family stayed at the latter site. Food dwindled, while starvation and exposure began to take lives.

Relief parties reached the camps in 1847, but rescue required repeated journeys across dangerous winter terrain. Eliza and her sisters left with the third relief party in March. Eliza was small enough to be carried. Her parents, George and Tamsen Donner, did not survive. For the children, reaching safety also meant entering life without them.

Decades later, Eliza Donner Houghton published her account of the expedition and attended the dedication of the Donner monument in 1918. Her name connects the winter camps to a long life afterwards, rather than ending her story at the moment of rescue. A survivor's later memoir needs to be read as testimony shaped by time, but it also restores family and individual memory to an event too often reduced to its most shocking details.

Sources

The route delays, winter entrapment and Eliza's rescue are documented. Her later memoir is survivor testimony, not a contemporaneous record of every event at both camps.

  1. Hogsback Summit Winter Views — National Park Service
  2. Eliza Donner Houghton — National Park Service